Which question is most likely to stimulate a thought-provoking discussion in a high school government class?

The question about potential consequences if the government ceased to exist in the United States is likely to generate a thought-provoking discussion because it invites students to engage critically with complex ideas about governance, society, and individual rights. This type of question encourages students to explore various perspectives, consider implications, and articulate their thoughts on the role of government in maintaining order, providing services, and protecting freedoms.

By contemplating the absence of government, students can discuss themes such as anarchy, social order, the rule of law, and the basic functions of government. This discussion can lead to deeper conversations about history, civics, and the current political climate, fostering a more profound understanding of their roles as citizens. Additionally, it can prompt students to think creatively about what a society without government might look like, encouraging imaginative yet analytical thinking.

In contrast, the other questions focus on factual recall and basic knowledge of government structure, which does not inherently stimulate the same level of discussion. Straightforward questions that require recollection of information may not engage students' critical thinking or personal interpretation, resulting in less dynamic classroom interactions.